The Mischief Trophy
Best Performance by a Pony Team
Donated by the Hennel Family
| Year | Name | Name | Name | Name | Name | Driver | Venue |
| 2001 | Rachel Haslau | Wandin Park | |||||
| 2002 | Rachel Haslau | Wandin Park | |||||
| 2003 | |||||||
| 2004 | Rachel Haslau | Wandin Park | |||||
| 2005 | Rachel Haslau | Romsey | |||||
| 2006 | Tya Annabel | Tya Aphrodite | Tya Charmer | Tya Honey Gold | Lenson Park Sovereign | Rachel Haslau | Catani |
| 2007 | Tya Annabel | Tya Aphrodite | Tya Charmer | Hasloch Park Blossom | Green Opal | Rachel Haslau | Catani |
| 2008 | Hasloch Park Placido Domingo | Lenson Park Sovereign | Hasloch Park Blossom | Tya Aphrodite | Tya Charmer | Rachel Haslau | Longwood |
| 2009 | Smudge | Smear | Smerk | Smarty | Wayne Armstrong | Wandin Park | |
| 2010 | Rosie | Ripple Brook Meg | Ripple Brook Cobber | Ripple Brook Token | Karen Rogers | Longwood | |
| 2011 | Rosie | Ripple Brook Meg | Ripple Brook Cobber | Ripple Brook Token | Karen Rogers | Inverleigh | |
| 2012 | No Award | Greenvale | |||||
| 2013 | Smudge | Smear | Smarty | Smoothie | Wayne Armstrong | Romsey | |
| 2014 | Rosie | Ripple Brook Meg | Ripple Brook Cobber | Ripple Brook Token | Karen Rogers | Koonoomoo | |
| 2015 | Speedy | Smear | Smarty | Smoothie | Wayne Armstrong | Inverleigh | |
| 2016 | Speedy | Smear | Smarty | Smoothie | Wayne Armstrong | Koonoomoo | |
| 2017 | Deejay Supernova | Pemberton Chitchat | Elargee Trevi | Riddell Ridge Painted Sioux | Barnhill Tuxedo | Rachel Haslau | Greenvale |
| 2018 | Finality Folly | Duckponds Chocolate | Duckponds Buzz Light Year | Duckponds Apache | Primrose Park Penman | Nicole Linic | Koonoomoo |
| 2019 | Carlyle Spartan | Carlyle Luke | Carlyle Pay Pal | Carlyle Danceman | Carlyle Shakespeare | Elizabeth Lawrence | Greenvale |
| 2020 | No Event | due to | Covid | ||||
| 2021 | Carlyle Spartan | Carlyle Shakespeare | Carlyle Tim | Carlyle Sunday Best | Carlyle Pay Pal | Ruby Lawrence | Longwood |
| 2022 | Mosman Park Vienna Woods | Mosman Park Sugar Plum | Mosman Park Fairytale | Westbury Dior | Rhiannon Damsma | Leighdale | |
| 2023 | No Entry | Greenvale |